Rode Rambler 40s last year, have been on Rambler 45s this year. For context, I weigh 240 so keep that in mind. The Ramblers are a great all around tire. We deal with quite a bit of fluffy, sandy spots as well as deep, fresh gravel that has been applied to road. Occasionally some mud too, where They surprised me with the traction.
I ran 40/32psi tubeless with the 40s and now 35/26 with the 45s. I have had one puncture I used a plug on but no other issues that the sealant didn’t take care of in about 1300 miles of riding 90% gravel roads.
I don’t have experience with the other tires you are looking at but can sure recommend the Ramblers.